PDA

View Full Version : Trans Pacific Partnership Is about Control, Not Free Trade



Chris
06-07-2015, 10:58 AM
As pointed out in this piece, opposition to free trade puts you squarely on the left.

Trans Pacific Partnership Is about Control, Not Free Trade (http://fee.org/anythingpeaceful/detail/trans-pacific-partnership-is-about-control-not-free-trade)


...Those in favor of free enterprise, free trade, capitalism, and private property rights should oppose the TPP and the fast-track authority that makes its passage more likely....

...both left and right are wrong about the TPP. The left is opposing the TPP for the wrong reasons, and the right and corporate interests (allied with Obama) are using disingenuous arguments to push the TPP.

...First, let’s not take the state at its word. It is undeniable that free trade is good. A smattering of basic economics is all one needs to grasp this simple point. When A and B trade, each is better off after the exchange.

...A real free trade policy would amount to a couple of sentences, not thousands of pages: one nation announcing that all imports and exports to and from that nation are to be exempt from duties, controls, quotas, tariffs. That is free trade. Instead, we have the managed trade of the last 60-70 years.

...Second, there are better ways to foster trade, namely: unilaterally reduce tariffs and trade barriers.

Third, the TPP aims to twist the arms of our trading partners to get them to adopt stronger, US-style intellectual property rights for the benefit of the US music, movie, and pharmaceutical industries, as has been happening for decades now.

...Leftists who oppose the TPP because they oppose free trade are wrong to oppose free trade, but they are also wrong in assuming that the TPP is really about free trade: it is about managed trade, and IP.

The TPP is just the latest instance of the US federal government employing its post-WWII dominance to advance the interests of the music, movie, and pharmaceutical industries in the US, at the expense of US consumers and foreigners....

PolWatch
06-07-2015, 11:55 AM
I may be completely missing the point of the trade agreements but one thing jumped out. Part of this proposal would require signing countries to recognize & extend our copy write laws to their nations.

One of the best stories I have read coming out of Asia is that of a golf club manufacturer who moved his operation. Cheap labor....great bargain. Until the factory authorized repair facilities in the US started getting clubs in for repair/replacement that looked just like the real product....but were cheap imitations. Turned out that the designs for the genuine items were ripped off before the Asian plant opened. Rip offs were being made before the real ones. Now, the golf club company wants the US to enforce our copy write laws on Asia.

How do they think Asia can offer such cheap manufacturing? We (the taxpayer) are supposed to pay for enforcement of our laws for overseas manufacturing. The new proposal looks like they have found a way to get American protections without paying American taxes or employing Americans.

NAFTA started the rush of American manufacturing overseas. We don't need more NAFTA type laws.

Chris
06-07-2015, 12:14 PM
All the protections in the world aren't going to stop fraud. But once word gets out, reputation will.

I think you'll find that it's not Americans in general who will be protected by these agreements but specific lobbying special interests.

Rufus
06-07-2015, 08:55 PM
TPP is NAFTA on steroids.