PDA

View Full Version : Donald Trump and the Sad Triumph of Right-Wing Political Correctness



Chris
08-23-2017, 09:36 AM
Donald Trump and the Sad Triumph of Right-Wing Political Correctness (http://reason.com/blog/2017/08/18/donald-trump-and-the-ultimate-triumph-of): "The president isn't attacking P.C., as he once promised. He's sanctioned its use among his followers."

His base then has no more rational argument for his policies than the left has against them.



Back at the 2015 event at which Donald Trump announced his bid for the presidency, his daughter Ivanka introduced her father as, first and foremost, an implacable foe of political correctness. "My father is the opposite of politically correct. He says what he means and he means what he says," she said.... In the first Republican primary debate, held in August of 2015, Trump himself reiterated that being anti-P.C. would be the hallmark of his political life, declaring, "I don't frankly have time for total political correctness."

It's ironic, then, that perhaps Trump's greatest accomplishment so far as president is to make it OK—or maybe even mandatory—for his followers to engage in the worst excesses of political correctness, especially its attempts to shut down debate and heterodox opinions through bullying, appeals to ad hominem attacks, and unthinking "whataboutism."

Among the Trump faithful, there are never legitimate grounds upon which to disagree with anything the billionaire says or does. If Barack Obama's most strident defenders were sometimes quick to claim any criticism of him was racist, thereby delegitimating honest disagreement, Trump's supporters are equally quick to denounce any dissent as proof positive of secret membership in Antifa, a pro-Hillary voting record, or a desperate attempt to look good among the communists who run the much-discussed-yet-little-seen Washington, D.C. cocktail party circuit.

Is it politically correct to expect the president of the United States to unequivocally denounce the racial theories and violence of neo-Nazis and white supremacists? For Donald Trump and his supporters, the answer is unambiguously yes and so even libertarian critics of the president who are unsurpassed in their contempt for collectivist racial theories and their defense of free speech (something Trump himself is not so good on) must be attacked for calling out Nazis as stupid, bigoted, and, well, definitionally un-American (didn't we fight a war against Nazism?). Don't you understand, Trump's supporters insist, that we need to fight progressives with the same tactics they use? If you hold him to basic standards of decency, competence, or comportment, they continue, you're as bad as the left (typically defined as libertarian-leaning Republican Sen. Jeff Flake and anyone to his left).

...



whataboutism has been covered here: http://thepoliticalforums.com/threads/85902-whataboutism?highlight=whataboutism

resister
08-23-2017, 09:43 AM
19619 Yeah, I think that opinion piece is incorrect, plenty of Trump supporters have been critical of certain actions.

Chris
08-23-2017, 09:45 AM
19619 Yeah, I think that opinion piece is incorrect, plenty of Trump supporters have been critical of certain actions.

The point of the piece though is that rather than arguing with leftist criticism, when they do occur, Trump and his supporters tend to play the leftist game of PC.

Tahuyaman
08-23-2017, 01:54 PM
Donald Trump and the Sad Triumph of Right-Wing Political Correctness
It looks like the left is now trying to redefine just what political correctness is. The article cited, doesn't seem to make any valid points.

Chris
08-23-2017, 03:02 PM
Donald Trump and the Sad Triumph of Right-Wing Political Correctness
It looks like the left is now trying to redefine just what political correctness is. The article cited, doesn't seem to make any valid points.

Read the rest at the link.

What it's talking about is the whataboutism (tu quoque) of the right who when confronted with the hate and violence retirn but what about Antifa. If you take Trump at face valie he did the same in reaction to the media. It's just not a rational argument.